Stuffed Pasta Shells

These cheesy stuffed pasta shells are filled with three types of cheese, spinach, basil, and delicious aromatics! This stuffed shells recipe is perfect for serving a large family or taking to a potluck.

Growing up any time my mom would ask me what I wanted for my birthday dinner, it would always be this stuffed shells recipe. I mean spinach, cheese, garlic… count me in!

Cooking

The most important tip to making this stuffed shells recipe, is cooking the pasta shells al dente. If the pasta shells are overcooked, they will be hard to stuff and will break apart. Remove the pasta once al dente and I even like to spray them down with cold water in the colander to ensure they stop cooking.

Stuffing

Next, in a skillet you’re going to sauté roughly chopped fresh spinach and minced garlic. Am I the only one that is always astounded when you put a WHOLE bag of spinach in the pan and then it shrinks down to fit in your palm? It gets me every time. I wouldn’t use frozen spinach, because it will make the filling watery.

After that you’re going to add the spinach mixture to a bowl, add mozzarella, ricotta, parmesan, one egg, crushed red pepper flakes, and freshly chopped basil. Then mix the whole thing up until all the ingredients are combined.

Stuffing the shells

It wasn’t until maybe the 20th time that I made this recipe, that I found a better way to stuff the shells. I’ve always used a spoon, but I ended up having more on me than in the actual shells [facepalm]. Putting the stuffed shells filling in a bag and piping it into the shells is easy and less messy.

I’m not much of a baker so I don’t have piping bags, instead I used a gallon sized ziplock bag. I emptied the stuffing inside, pushed it to one corner, and cut a hole to allow the stuffing to squeeze out. Ahhhhh much better.

I spread arrabbiata sauce on the bottom of the baking dish. I like using arrabbiata because it gives the dish a nice kick. If you don’t like spicy you can sub your favorite red sauce.

If you have filling leftover, but no more room to add shells you can add some more filling to the ones that you may have skimped on. Add some cheese on top (the theme here is cheese on cheese clearly), cover with foil and into the oven they go.

Final Dish

Remove the foil at the end and broil to get cheese brown and bubbly. Top with freshly chopped basil and serve!

These stuffed pasta shells are the most requested by my family/friends when I ask them what they want me to make and I know your family will love it too!

Love this stuffed shells recipe, but looking for a low carb option? Try my stuffed zucchini rolls, which has the same stuffing with hot Italian sausage inside!

Important Tips/FAQ’s

• Cook the pasta shells al dente, so they do not fall apart when stuffing and cooking.
• You can use a spoon to stuff shells. For ease and less mess, use a ziplock bag to pipe the filling into the shells
• I use arrabbiata sauce to surround the shells, if you do not like spicy sub your favorite red sauce
• If you want to prepare in advance and freeze: Follow steps 1-5 in the recipe card. Once you have stuffed the pasta shells, place them in a freezer friendly bag. When ready to bake, proceed with the red sauce, and add 5-10 minutes to bake time

Things you’ll need:

• Pasta pot
• skillet to sauté spinach
• large bowl to mix ingredients
• gallon ziplock bag (if piping)
• large baking dish
• aluminum foil

Visit my store for useful tools and favorite kitchen items

Affiliate notice: The links above are affiliate links meaning I do make a small profit from your purchases. Your price is not affected by this commission. Thank you for supporting Girl with the Iron Cast

See the video below for cooking and assembly!

Print